raw_payload
{
"by": "watermelon0",
"id": 48323869,
"url": "https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2026/its-hard-to-justify-framework-12/",
"kids": [
48326142,
48326331,
48326188,
48329459,
48327018,
48326031,
48326043,
48324641,
48324145,
48329179,
48326138,
48326032,
48324450,
48324753,
48328668,
48329174,
48325415,
48329434,
48328704,
48328780,
48324832,
48329493,
48324579,
48325971,
48329118,
48327830,
48328973,
48324609,
48327134,
48327813,
48324437,
48326833,
48328135,
48327034,
48327177,
48329274,
48328593,
48327117,
48325015,
48327968,
48326424,
48328606,
48324878,
48325908,
48328266,
48324583,
48326100,
48324885,
48327881,
48327321,
48324561,
48327330,
48324321,
48324496,
48327784,
48328498,
48326811,
48329465,
48324943,
48325089,
48324670,
48324586,
48325309,
48328126,
48324782,
48326203
],
"text": "<a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPVAnwuSjfk\" rel=\"nofollow\">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPVAnwuSjfk</a>",
"time": 1780066531,
"type": "story",
"score": 167,
"title": "It's hard to justify buying a Framework 12",
"descendants": 319
}source_raw_snapshot
{
"id": "c38b9ac7-df63-4166-90a0-c0057c9a9cba",
"daily_ranking_item_id": "87e24bf0-fc08-462c-9623-25f26228ab96",
"source": "hacker_news",
"external_id": "48323869",
"fetched_at": "2026-05-29T22:01:20.907Z",
"story_raw": {
"by": "watermelon0",
"id": 48323869,
"url": "https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2026/its-hard-to-justify-framework-12/",
"kids": [
48326142,
48326331,
48326188,
48329459,
48327018,
48326031,
48326043,
48324641,
48324145,
48329179,
48326138,
48326032,
48324450,
48324753,
48328668,
48329174,
48325415,
48329434,
48328704,
48328780,
48324832,
48329493,
48324579,
48325971,
48329118,
48327830,
48328973,
48324609,
48327134,
48327813,
48324437,
48326833,
48328135,
48327034,
48327177,
48329274,
48328593,
48327117,
48325015,
48327968,
48326424,
48328606,
48324878,
48325908,
48328266,
48324583,
48326100,
48324885,
48327881,
48327321,
48324561,
48327330,
48324321,
48324496,
48327784,
48328498,
48326811,
48329465,
48324943,
48325089,
48324670,
48324586,
48325309,
48328126,
48324782,
48326203
],
"text": "<a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPVAnwuSjfk\" rel=\"nofollow\">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPVAnwuSjfk</a>",
"time": 1780066531,
"type": "story",
"score": 167,
"title": "It's hard to justify buying a Framework 12",
"descendants": 319
},
"stats_raw": {
"time": 1780066531,
"score": 167,
"descendants": 319
},
"aux_raw": {
"external_url": "https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2026/its-hard-to-justify-framework-12/",
"hn_comment_url": "https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48323869",
"normalized_text": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPVAnwuSjfk",
"external_article": {
"title": "It",
"excerpt": "My nephew just graduated high school, and wants a laptop. When he decides what computer to buy, price (or more precisely, value ) is the most important attribute.\n\nApple's MacBook Neo upended the 'value laptop' equation—Apple's not supposed to be both the cheapest option and the best value... but it seems like that's squarely where the Neo landed for the good-but-cheap laptop category.\n\nMy nephew is also my godson, and to kick off his computing journey, I thought I'd let him choose from a Framework 12 I bought to test, or the MacBook Neo I bought a couple months ago to use around the studio.\n\nI had already put both laptops through my benchmark gauntlet, which revealed one theme: the Mac is faster (in most cases), more efficient, quieter, built better, has a much nicer display, and costs much less.\n\nThe Framework is more expensive, slower (in most cases), louder (its fan ramps up quite often), has a pretty poor display, but it is a touchscreen, has a 360° hinge, and is more repairable and upgradeable 1 .\n\nThe problem is, for an overall worse experience, are you willing to pay 20-40% more? Because that's the difference for the low-end Framework, which starts at $749 for a DIY edition",
"final_url": "https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2026/its-hard-to-justify-framework-12/",
"fetched_at": "2026-05-29T22:01:18.169Z",
"description": "My nephew just graduated high school, and wants a laptop. When he decides what computer to buy, price (or more precisely, value) is the most important attribute. Apple"
},
"selected_comments": [
{
"id": 48326142,
"raw": {
"by": "whimblepop",
"id": 48326142,
"kids": [
48327178,
48329573,
48326547,
48329383,
48327417,
48326436
],
"text": "I was seduced by Apple Silicon after experiencing the exceptional battery life and performance. Those things are great, as are the screens and the speakers.<p>But I'm still excited about the Framework 12 because I don't love macOS. I don't need an alternative to beat Apple on every line of the spec sheet. I just need them to align with my values, support Linux well, and cross a certain "good enough" threshold. The latest laptops from Framework meet all of those requirements, and I'm excited to buy one after I've saved up enough money. I've missed Plasma for a long time. At the same time, I wouldn't even consider a MacBook Neo.",
"time": 1780074658,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
"body": "I was seduced by Apple Silicon after experiencing the exceptional battery life and performance. Those things are great, as are the screens and the speakers. But I'm still excited about the Framework 12 because I don't love macOS. I don't need an alternative to beat Apple on every line of the spec sheet. I just need them to align with my values, support Linux well, and cross a certain \"good enough\" threshold. The latest laptops from Framework meet all of those requirements, and I'm excited to buy one after I've saved up enough money. I've missed Plasma for a long time. At the same time, I wouldn't even consider a MacBook Neo.",
"is_op": false,
"author": "whimblepop",
"raw_body": "I was seduced by Apple Silicon after experiencing the exceptional battery life and performance. Those things are great, as are the screens and the speakers.<p>But I'm still excited about the Framework 12 because I don't love macOS. I don't need an alternative to beat Apple on every line of the spec sheet. I just need them to align with my values, support Linux well, and cross a certain "good enough" threshold. The latest laptops from Framework meet all of those requirements, and I'm excited to buy one after I've saved up enough money. I've missed Plasma for a long time. At the same time, I wouldn't even consider a MacBook Neo.",
"created_at": 1780074658,
"reply_count": 6
},
{
"id": 48326331,
"raw": {
"by": "benoau",
"id": 48326331,
"kids": [
48328058,
48326973,
48327361
],
"text": "As nice as Apple's hardware is it's all undermined by who they are as a company, intentionally limiting their devices more and more while they relentlessly argue in courts and to regulators that we owe them more and more for using our devices.<p>Rosetta 2's retirement announcement was when I realized I won't buy another Mac, I'm not interested in a computer that is preoccupied with stopping me from running software. Work can buy them for me but I won't spend my money on a platform like that anymore.<p>Depending on how their Supreme Court argument goes in a few weeks I will stop buying an iPhone too, if they establish the precedent that any method of paying for Netflix deserves a $5/month fee then they will leverage that to extract the same fee everywhere else.",
"time": 1780075477,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
"body": "As nice as Apple's hardware is it's all undermined by who they are as a company, intentionally limiting their devices more and more while they relentlessly argue in courts and to regulators that we owe them more and more for using our devices. Rosetta 2's retirement announcement was when I realized I won't buy another Mac, I'm not interested in a computer that is preoccupied with stopping me from running software. Work can buy them for me but I won't spend my money on a platform like that anymore. Depending on how their Supreme Court argument goes in a few weeks I will stop buying an iPhone too, if they establish the precedent that any method of paying for Netflix deserves a $5/month fee then they will leverage that to extract the same fee everywhere else.",
"is_op": false,
"author": "benoau",
"raw_body": "As nice as Apple's hardware is it's all undermined by who they are as a company, intentionally limiting their devices more and more while they relentlessly argue in courts and to regulators that we owe them more and more for using our devices.<p>Rosetta 2's retirement announcement was when I realized I won't buy another Mac, I'm not interested in a computer that is preoccupied with stopping me from running software. Work can buy them for me but I won't spend my money on a platform like that anymore.<p>Depending on how their Supreme Court argument goes in a few weeks I will stop buying an iPhone too, if they establish the precedent that any method of paying for Netflix deserves a $5/month fee then they will leverage that to extract the same fee everywhere else.",
"created_at": 1780075477,
"reply_count": 3
},
{
"id": 48326188,
"raw": {
"by": "robspairpears",
"id": 48326188,
"kids": [
48326972,
48328177,
48328640,
48327059
],
"text": "Bought the Framework 12 as my personal daily driver (limited hobby projects, Obsidian, light browsing) and for the hardware to grow with my use cases.<p>So even if I could get more bang for my buck with a Neo (yeah, I could), the tinkerability and repairability win over raw specs for what I actually use it for. Did I pay more for a less polished, less powerful machine? Yep. Is it enjoyable to use and fully capable of meeting my requirements? Yep.<p>Came to bikeshed but the video was more nuanced and fair than this title.",
"time": 1780074818,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
"body": "Bought the Framework 12 as my personal daily driver (limited hobby projects, Obsidian, light browsing) and for the hardware to grow with my use cases. So even if I could get more bang for my buck with a Neo (yeah, I could), the tinkerability and repairability win over raw specs for what I actually use it for. Did I pay more for a less polished, less powerful machine? Yep. Is it enjoyable to use and fully capable of meeting my requirements? Yep. Came to bikeshed but the video was more nuanced and fair than this title.",
"is_op": false,
"author": "robspairpears",
"raw_body": "Bought the Framework 12 as my personal daily driver (limited hobby projects, Obsidian, light browsing) and for the hardware to grow with my use cases.<p>So even if I could get more bang for my buck with a Neo (yeah, I could), the tinkerability and repairability win over raw specs for what I actually use it for. Did I pay more for a less polished, less powerful machine? Yep. Is it enjoyable to use and fully capable of meeting my requirements? Yep.<p>Came to bikeshed but the video was more nuanced and fair than this title.",
"created_at": 1780074818,
"reply_count": 4
},
{
"id": 48329459,
"raw": {
"by": "DanieleSalatti",
"id": 48329459,
"kids": [
48329475
],
"text": "> The problem is, for an overall worse experience, are you willing to pay 20-40% more?<p>This is subjective. For me: yes. It buys me a lot, repairability and not being in the apple ecosystem are two things I value enough that it makes sense for me to go with Framework. It flips it to an overall better experience.",
"time": 1780089737,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
"body": "> The problem is, for an overall worse experience, are you willing to pay 20-40% more? This is subjective. For me: yes. It buys me a lot, repairability and not being in the apple ecosystem are two things I value enough that it makes sense for me to go with Framework. It flips it to an overall better experience.",
"is_op": false,
"author": "DanieleSalatti",
"raw_body": "> The problem is, for an overall worse experience, are you willing to pay 20-40% more?<p>This is subjective. For me: yes. It buys me a lot, repairability and not being in the apple ecosystem are two things I value enough that it makes sense for me to go with Framework. It flips it to an overall better experience.",
"created_at": 1780089737,
"reply_count": 1
},
{
"id": 48327018,
"raw": {
"by": "drnick1",
"id": 48327018,
"kids": [
48328641,
48328395
],
"text": "The point of the Framework is to run Linux, and not to be part of Apple's ecosystem. I don't want my computer to update itself without my permission, report telemetry to Apple, upload anything to any "cloud" or request that I log into something. If you don't think this is a big deal, wait until an age or identity verification law is passed somewhere, and Apple will enforce it against your will, on the computer that you bought and thought that you owned.",
"time": 1780078190,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
"body": "The point of the Framework is to run Linux, and not to be part of Apple's ecosystem. I don't want my computer to update itself without my permission, report telemetry to Apple, upload anything to any \"cloud\" or request that I log into something. If you don't think this is a big deal, wait until an age or identity verification law is passed somewhere, and Apple will enforce it against your will, on the computer that you bought and thought that you owned.",
"is_op": false,
"author": "drnick1",
"raw_body": "The point of the Framework is to run Linux, and not to be part of Apple's ecosystem. I don't want my computer to update itself without my permission, report telemetry to Apple, upload anything to any "cloud" or request that I log into something. If you don't think this is a big deal, wait until an age or identity verification law is passed somewhere, and Apple will enforce it against your will, on the computer that you bought and thought that you owned.",
"created_at": 1780078190,
"reply_count": 2
}
],
"presentation_fields": {
"title": "It's hard to justify buying a Framework 12",
"tagline": "www.jeffgeerling.com",
"website_url": "https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2026/its-hard-to-justify-framework-12/",
"canonical_url": "https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48323869"
},
"external_url_hostname": "www.jeffgeerling.com",
"selected_comments_raw": [
{
"by": "whimblepop",
"id": 48326142,
"kids": [
48327178,
48329573,
48326547,
48329383,
48327417,
48326436
],
"text": "I was seduced by Apple Silicon after experiencing the exceptional battery life and performance. Those things are great, as are the screens and the speakers.<p>But I'm still excited about the Framework 12 because I don't love macOS. I don't need an alternative to beat Apple on every line of the spec sheet. I just need them to align with my values, support Linux well, and cross a certain "good enough" threshold. The latest laptops from Framework meet all of those requirements, and I'm excited to buy one after I've saved up enough money. I've missed Plasma for a long time. At the same time, I wouldn't even consider a MacBook Neo.",
"time": 1780074658,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
{
"by": "benoau",
"id": 48326331,
"kids": [
48328058,
48326973,
48327361
],
"text": "As nice as Apple's hardware is it's all undermined by who they are as a company, intentionally limiting their devices more and more while they relentlessly argue in courts and to regulators that we owe them more and more for using our devices.<p>Rosetta 2's retirement announcement was when I realized I won't buy another Mac, I'm not interested in a computer that is preoccupied with stopping me from running software. Work can buy them for me but I won't spend my money on a platform like that anymore.<p>Depending on how their Supreme Court argument goes in a few weeks I will stop buying an iPhone too, if they establish the precedent that any method of paying for Netflix deserves a $5/month fee then they will leverage that to extract the same fee everywhere else.",
"time": 1780075477,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
{
"by": "robspairpears",
"id": 48326188,
"kids": [
48326972,
48328177,
48328640,
48327059
],
"text": "Bought the Framework 12 as my personal daily driver (limited hobby projects, Obsidian, light browsing) and for the hardware to grow with my use cases.<p>So even if I could get more bang for my buck with a Neo (yeah, I could), the tinkerability and repairability win over raw specs for what I actually use it for. Did I pay more for a less polished, less powerful machine? Yep. Is it enjoyable to use and fully capable of meeting my requirements? Yep.<p>Came to bikeshed but the video was more nuanced and fair than this title.",
"time": 1780074818,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
{
"by": "DanieleSalatti",
"id": 48329459,
"kids": [
48329475
],
"text": "> The problem is, for an overall worse experience, are you willing to pay 20-40% more?<p>This is subjective. For me: yes. It buys me a lot, repairability and not being in the apple ecosystem are two things I value enough that it makes sense for me to go with Framework. It flips it to an overall better experience.",
"time": 1780089737,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
},
{
"by": "drnick1",
"id": 48327018,
"kids": [
48328641,
48328395
],
"text": "The point of the Framework is to run Linux, and not to be part of Apple's ecosystem. I don't want my computer to update itself without my permission, report telemetry to Apple, upload anything to any "cloud" or request that I log into something. If you don't think this is a big deal, wait until an age or identity verification law is passed somewhere, and Apple will enforce it against your will, on the computer that you bought and thought that you owned.",
"time": 1780078190,
"type": "comment",
"parent": 48323869
}
]
},
"selection_meta": {
"discussion_depth": "top_comments_v1",
"external_article": {
"status": "ok",
"final_url": "https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2026/its-hard-to-justify-framework-12/",
"status_code": 200,
"content_type": "text/html",
"failure_reason": null
},
"snapshot_version": "hn_story_v3",
"selected_comments_count": 5,
"external_article_resolved": true,
"text_normalization_applied": true
},
"created_at": "2026-05-29T22:01:21.157Z",
"updated_at": "2026-05-29T22:01:21.157Z"
}